The Impact of Women-Centric Laws on Men: Concerns and Misuse

India has implemented various laws that empower women and protect them from violence, abuse, and discrimination. While these laws are very important to ensure women's safety and rights, there are concerns regarding misuse in certain cases where the laws may work against men. Critics argue that though these laws are well-intentioned, sometimes they are misused to harass men and, in some extreme cases, even threaten to kill them. This blog is a journey through malpractices associated with women-centric laws and their effects on men.

1. Women Protective Laws in India

India has introduced various women-oriented laws over the years to protect and safeguard women against violence and exploitation. There are several women-centric enactments which are listed here below:

Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (PWDVA): The enactment has been made primarily to safeguard a woman against numerous forms of domestic violence like physical, psychological, and economic abuse.

The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act, 2013: The act aims to prevent the sexual harassment of women at work.

Section 498A of Indian Penal Code (IPC): It criminalizes acts of cruelty towards a woman by her husband or her husband's relatives and is frequently invoked in cases of dowry harassment and domestic abuse.

promise of marriage(BNS): According to this rule, women have exclusive rights to take legal action against men in cases where a promise of marriage is made and later broken. If a man promises marriage and later refuses to fulfill the commitment, the woman can file a complaint, and the law allows her to seek legal redress.

While these laws and many other laws are of prime importance in protecting women, there is also a possibility of misuse with malicious intent.

2. Misuse of Women-Centric Laws: The Possibility and Its Impact on Men

a. Misuse of Section 498A (IPC) – Domestic Violence and Dowry Harassment

IPC's section 498A is perhaps India's most discussed law, whereby it was created to serve for the protection of women in dowry harassment and cruelties but is still misused quite frequently:

False Allegations: In dowry harassment or cruelty cases during marital disputes, the law is often misused to lodge false accusations. In most cases, the law facilitates immediate arrests without proper investigation, which can cause undue suffering for men.

Long-Drawn Legal Harassment: Men who are falsely accused of dowry harassment or domestic cruelty may be harassed for years even after acquittal. The emotional, financial, and social cost of such battles can be devastating.

Social Isolation: False accusations lead to extreme social isolation, reputational damage, and strained relationships. Men lose their jobs, suffer public humiliation, and face extreme mental distress.

b. Impact of Wrongful Sexual Harassment Complaints

Though the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act, 2013 was created to protect women from sexual harassment at workplaces, this act has a possibility of being misused in the following ways:

False Accusations: Some women may fake false accusations of sexual harassment with the sole motive of avenging some personal grudges or seeking monetary compensations. False accusations on these grounds have a terribly shattering impact on any man's career, repute, and mental equilibrium.

Inadequate Protection Measures: The law seeks to safeguard women, but the safeguards against malicious or false accusations of men are very limited. Thus, the protection afforded to one party has the opposite effect on the other, and that party becomes a victim of exploitation.

c. Misuse of the Promise of Marriage under BNS

This provision does not extend the same rights to men in similar situations, where men may not have the legal grounds to pursue action if a woman breaks a promise of marriage. Critics of this rule argue that it reinforces gender bias in legal matters related to relationships and could potentially lead to the misuse of the law.

d. Gender Bias in Legal Frameworks

Another problem with the present law is that most of the legislation against women abuse lacks corresponding laws regarding men abuse. For instance:

Inadequate Remedies Available to Male Victim of Domestic Violence: Men becoming victims of domestic violence or any form of abuse do not have ample legal recourse and remedies against their abuser. Women have PWDVA as well as section 498A, among others; however, their male counterparts do not share the same luck.

Gender-Biased Legal Preference: Most of the current legislations are based on the understanding that in any case of domestic violence or harassment, the woman is the victim and the man is the abuser. This discrimination can cause an imbalance in the judicial system, which may not ensure that justice is properly delivered, especially in cases where the men are victims.

3. Psychological and Monetary Effects on Men

Misuse of women-centric laws could be extremely damaging to the emotional and financial well-being of men, especially when they are falsely accused. Some of the effects include:

Emotional Stress: False charges of dowry harassment, domestic violence, or sexual harassment can be very damaging emotionally. Stress and depression caused by these accusations can, in extreme cases, make people want to commit or attempt suicide.

Financial Burden: The financial burden of litigation in itself can be substantial; men even have to fight false accusations on occasion for years. On top of that, mental strain, added to it, leaves a man totally at a vulnerable financial stance, especially when he forms the family breadwinner.

Professional and Social Life: Wrongful allegations can be highly damaging to men's professions, resulting in losing employment and friendships with family members and friends. Such defamation often remains even after an acquittal for many years.

4. Recommendations for Judicial and Social Changes

There is a need for legal as well as social reforms which can check the improper applications of women-centric laws and further harassment of men.

a. Judicial Inquisition and Monitoring

Intensified Scrutiny of Complaints: Allegations need to be more strictly scrutinized, especially where dowry harassment and domestic violence is concerned, in order that claims are bona fide and not malicious.

Pre-arrest Bail: In cases wherein Section 498A or similar provisions are invoked, there should be provisions for pre-arrest bail so that men are not arrested without a fair investigation, and guilt is not presumed automatically.

b. Gender-Neutral Laws

Protections for Male Victims: Legal protections against domestic violence and harassment should be gender neutral. Protection should be afforded to all men who suffer abuse and subjected to the same protection as women.

Deterrence for False Accusations: Whoever makes false or malicious claims should face stiff penalties with no gender difference.

c. Public Awareness and Sensitization

Raising Awareness: Public awareness campaigns should be launched to educate both men and women about their rights and responsibilities in cases of domestic violence and harassment. These campaigns would promote fair treatment and foster understanding between the genders.

Conclusion: Striking a Balance Between Women’s Rights and Men’s Protection

While women-centric laws have contributed a lot to the empowerment of women in India, more recently, there has been concern about their misuse—especially when men are concerned. Accusations against male victims of domestic violence by female perpetrators and the inability of the law to prevent or punish such cases create legitimate grounds for demanding changes in the law.

A balanced legal framework is of paramount importance—one that guards men and women equally against all abuses, harassment, and false accusations. A system that moves toward gender-neutral laws and toward judicial accountability will only usher in a more just and balanced legal system with equity and equal treatment for everyone.

How PrimeBalance Advisory Can Help in Legal Matters

PrimeBalance Advisory provides expert legal guidance for individuals facing the misuse of women-centric laws. They assist in understanding your rights and navigating the complexities of cases like false accusations under Section 498A or sexual harassment laws. The advisory offers support in securing pre-arrest bail, ensuring a fair investigation, and helps in minimizing the legal impact of wrongful accusations. With PrimeBalance's legal expertise, men can effectively challenge false allegations and work toward a fair resolution.

Primebalance Advisory